About Jennys Baking Co
Jenny's Baking Co. is a bakery at 1711 N College Ave, Suite 105. Its posted in-store hours are Wednesday and Saturday mornings and Thursday and Friday until early afternoon, and they may change. Its baked goods are also sold daily at Bethel Lane Farm Stop while supplies last.
The menu features cinnamon rolls with vanilla icing, with frozen take-and-bake rolls also available. Other items include muffins, crumb coffee cake, quiche, pizza rolls, poptarts and scones.
The bakery also makes custom cakes and cupcakes in many flavors, and takes orders or quote requests. The site has a cookie gallery, take-and-bake treats and gift certificates.
In a 2026 No Dishes Podcast episode, owner Jenny Regester said regulars can reserve items from her weekly menu, posted on Sunday night, by emailing an order, and she holds them at the counter. She also takes corporate, IU and wedding orders and sells leftovers at the Bloomington Farm Stop. She is known for cinnamon rolls, custom cakes and take-and-bake treats.
On the No Dishes Podcast
-
Jenny's Baking Co. owner Jenny Regester
Out-of-this world cinnamon rolls, custom cakes, and take-n-bake treats, Jenny's Baking Co. truly does it all! Jenny Regester joins us on the pod to tshare her story of growing her passion into a full time business, the challenges…
The No Dishes Podcast with Jordan Davis, shared with permission. More episodes



